Skip to content
All posts

Stop Chasing the Modern Data Stack. Start with the Questions.

The "Modern Data Stack" is the tech industry's favorite buzzword. It's a constantly shifting landscape of logos—Snowflake, Fivetran, dbt, Airflow, Prefect—all promising to unlock the power of your data.

But here’s the uncomfortable truth: the Modern Data Stack, on its own, is just an ingredient list. It's not a recipe for success.

I've seen too many companies spend millions on a beautiful, state-of-the-art collection of tools only to end up with the same problems they had before: confused business users, questionable ROI, and a more expensive, complex system to maintain. They bought the best ingredients but had no idea what meal they were cooking.

They fail because they start in the wrong place. They start by asking, "What tools should we use?"

The only right place to start is with a much simpler, more powerful question: "What business decisions do we want to make that we can't make today?"

The Question-First Framework

To build a data platform that delivers real value, you must work backward from the business outcome, not forward from the technology. I call this the Question-First Framework. It’s a simple, three-step process that ensures every technical decision is directly tied to a business need.

Step 1: Start with the End in Mind - The Business Questions

Before you write a single line of code or book a single sales demo, sit down with your business leaders. Ask them:

  • What are the top three questions you wish you could answer about your customers, products, or operations?
  • If you had perfect data, what decision would you make tomorrow?
  • Where are we flying blind as a business?

Are you trying to reduce customer churn? Understand which marketing channels are most effective? Optimize inventory levels? These questions—not a list of tools—are the true foundation of your data strategy.

Step 2: Work Backward to the Data

Once you have a clear business question, the next step becomes logical: what data do we need to answer it?

If your question is about customer churn, you'll need data from your payment system (e.g., Stripe), your customer support platform (e.g., Zendesk), and your application's usage logs. This step immediately defines the scope of your data integration and modeling efforts. You're no longer just collecting all data "just in case"; you're purposefully gathering the specific ingredients needed for your recipe.

[Diagram: A top-down flowchart or funnel titled 'The Question-First Framework'. The top layer is 'Business Questions', flowing down to 'Required Data & Insights', which flows down to the bottom layer, 'Technology & Tools'.]

Step 3: Let the Strategy Choose the Stack

Only now, at the very end, do we talk about technology. When you know the questions you need to answer and the data you need to answer them, choosing the right tools becomes a logical conclusion, not a speculative guess.

  • Need to integrate data from Stripe and Zendesk? Now you can evaluate data movers like Fivetran or Airbyte.
  • Need to join that data together and calculate a customer health score? Now you know you need a transformation tool like dbt.
  • Does the business need to see this data updated daily or in real-time? The answer to that question will determine the right data warehouse and orchestration tools for the job.

Your strategy dictates the architecture. Your stack is now a defensible, purpose-built solution to a specific business problem, not just a collection of popular logos.

A Strategy is Your Advantage, Not a Stack

Anyone can buy the tools of the Modern Data Stack. It is a commodity. A clear, business-driven data strategy, however, is a powerful and rare competitive advantage.

By starting with the right questions, you ensure that every dollar, every hire, and every hour of engineering effort is focused on a single goal: delivering tangible business value.

Ready to build a data strategy that delivers real business value, not just a collection of new tools? Let's start by asking the right questions together. Contact Us

See the Framework in Action: The Data Maturity Journey

The Question-First Framework provides the "why" behind any successful data initiative. But what does the "how" look like in practice? Our 5-part Data Maturity Journey series walks through the key stages of applying this strategy—from migrating legacy systems to delivering real business value.